News
Bots and royalties: judge dismisses RBX's Spotify lawsuit with prejudice

The class action on the streams that would have inflated Drake's numbers has been definitively rejected: according to the court, Spotify has no legal duty towards the entitled individuals. The appeal is announced.
On October 23, federal judge Josephine L. Staton of the Central District of California granted Spotify's dismissal request. The lawsuit was brought by Eric Dwayne Collins, the rapper known as RBX, and was rejected "with prejudice", meaning it cannot be resubmitted. Collins accused the platform of tolerating a network of automated accounts that would have inflated Drake's ratings. This is stated in the 16-page order (case 2:25-cv-10525), relaunched by Digital Music News on October 26th and by Music Business Worldwide on the 27th.
What the prosecution claimed
It all starts from the pro-rata model. Every month Spotify collects subscriptions and advertising in a single box and divides it based on the share of plays for each song. As a result, each fake stream takes away a small portion of royalties from everyone else. According to MBW, the quote estimated at least $600 million stolen and alleged that a significant portion of Drake's approximately 37 billion streams in 48 months were not authentic. It also accused Spotify of applying anti-fraud rules rigorously to small artists and leniently to large numbers. Drake was not among those in attendance. There were two charges: negligence and violation of California's Unfair Competition Law (UCL).
Because the court said no
This is the second failure: in June the case was rejected leaving the possibility of correcting it. Now, we read in the order, between RBX and Spotify there is only a commercial relationship, which does not create a duty to protect it from the actions of third parties. The phrase about the commitment to guaranteeing a "level playing field", i.e. equal conditions for all, is considered an aspiration, not a verifiable fact. For the statement about daily "cleaning" of streams, RBX has not proven it to be false. As for the UCL, the law protects consumers and competitors, and the plaintiff has indicated no such harm. The court also recalled that Spotify makes public the minimum stream and listener thresholds. One point needs to be made clear: The court did not determine whether Drake's numbers were inflated. He took the allegations at face value and concluded that, even so, they were not enough to support a case.
What changes for those who publish music
For independent artists and labels, the legal path against the effects of artificial streaming is narrowing. At least in this court, the fight against bots remains entrusted to the internal rules of the platform and does not arise from a legal obligation towards each entitled person. RBX attorney Mark Pifko told Rolling Stone (quoted by MBW) that "an appeal is likely." The appeal would go to the federal Ninth Circuit. For those who distribute music, the decision brings attention to a concrete point: transparency on anti-fraud controls is an issue to be negotiated in contracts and relations with distributors, because the court does not consider it a right to be enforced.
TAG: Spotify, artificial streaming, royalties, pro-rata, music rights, Drake



